Mad Hatter spice has a madly bizarre flavor profile. It's akin to dancing on the edge of a teacup, forcing your tastebuds on a rollercoaster ride. One taste you might be carried off the honeyed delight of nutmeg, and the next, whoosh!, you're assaulted with a punch of black pepper. Bits and Pieces: A dash of mystery Nutmeg Ginger Star Anise It'